For most kitchens we remodel, quartz is the right countertop: it doesn’t need sealing, holds up to daily use and comes in a huge range of looks. Granite is a great choice if you want natural stone, marble and quartzite are for people who love the look and accept some care, and butcher block or laminate have their place on an island or in a laundry room. With us, quartz for a medium kitchen usually runs $6,000 to $8,000 installed. Below is how each material compares, what it costs, and how to pick one that works with your cabinets.

How do the main countertop materials compare?
Quartz
Engineered from crushed stone and resin. It’s non-porous, so it doesn’t need sealing and resists stains. It comes in solid whites, concrete looks and marble-style veining. It’s what most of our customers pick. Two things to know: it doesn’t love direct heat (use a trivet), and most quartz is made for indoor use, so it’s not the pick for an outdoor kitchen or a spot that bakes in afternoon sun.
With us: three levels, Best Value, Mid Level and High End. Best Value is what most customers choose and what our starting prices are built on. Template, fabrication, install, a standard edge and an undermount sink cutout are included at every level.
New countertops are included in every Bayshore kitchen remodel range. Quartz for a medium kitchen typically runs $6,000–$8,000 on its own. With cabinet refinishing or refacing, new countertops are optional and always go in before the cabinet work.
Typical ranges from our recent projects. Your written estimate, built after we see your space, is what your project is priced on.
Granite
Natural stone, very durable and heat-resistant, with no two slabs alike. It needs sealing from time to time. Granite is a great fit if you want real stone. The busy speckled patterns from the 2000s have given way to calmer, more subtle slabs.
Marble and quartzite
Marble is beautiful and stays cool, which bakers love, but it etches and stains more easily. Quartzite is a natural stone that can look like marble and is much harder. Both are higher-end choices. If you love the marble look but want less care, a veined quartz gets you close.
Solid surface
Acrylic-based products like Corian. Seamless and repairable, but softer and less heat-tolerant than stone or quartz. More common in older kitchens and some condos than in new remodels today.
Laminate
The most affordable option, with many colors and patterns. It works well in a laundry room, garage or rental. It doesn’t take an undermount sink well and can’t handle heat or standing water at the seams.
Butcher block and wood
Warm and a nice contrast on an island, especially against white or painted cabinets. It needs oiling and doesn’t belong right next to the sink in most kitchens.
Concrete and tile
Concrete can look great but can crack and needs sealing. Tile counters are rare now because of the grout lines. If you love the concrete look, a concrete-style quartz is the low-risk way to get it.
What makes a countertop cost more?
- The level or slab you pick. Stepping up from Best Value to High End quartz, or choosing an exotic stone.
- How much counter you have. The price climbs through the grades and then flattens out. Past that point, it mostly goes up when the kitchen needs another slab, often because of a big island.
- Edge profile. A standard eased edge is included. Mitered, ogee or thicker built-up edges cost more.
- Cutouts and extras. Extra sink or cooktop cutouts, a waterfall end on the island, or a full-height quartz backsplash.
How do you pick a countertop that works with your cabinets?
Pick the cabinets first, then the countertop. A simple rule that works: contrast. Dark or colored cabinets look great with a light top. White cabinets look great with a top that has some movement or a little warmth. Bring a cabinet door or sample to the slab yard, and look at the countertop under your kitchen’s actual light before you commit. You can browse the cabinet colors, quartz and tile we use in our Design Portal to start narrowing it down.
Don’t forget the backsplash. It goes in after the countertop and should be picked to work with it. Most kitchen backsplashes run $2,000 to $3,500 installed with us. And finish with the hardware; our guide to selecting cabinet hardware picks up from here.

Can you replace just the countertops?
Yes, if your cabinets are solid. Many homeowners pair new quartz with cabinet refinishing (from $5,000) or cabinet refacing (from $7,000), plus a new backsplash. With countertops and backsplash, that combined job usually takes 2 to 3 weeks. A straight countertop swap usually doesn’t need a permit, but a licensed plumber still disconnects and reconnects the sink and faucet. One thing to check first: old cabinets have to be level and strong enough to carry stone, and the old top can sometimes damage the cabinets on the way out. We look at that before you commit.
How long do new countertops take?
The fabricator templates once the cabinets are set. In a full remodel, that means after new cabinets are installed. From template to install is commonly one to two weeks. Install day itself is usually a single day, then the plumber reconnects the sink. The backsplash follows. In a full kitchen remodel, the countertop window is the one gap in the schedule you’ll notice. See how long a kitchen remodel takes.

Frequently asked questions
Is quartz or granite better?
For most busy households, quartz, because it doesn’t need sealing and is very consistent. Granite is a great choice if you want natural stone and better heat resistance. Both last for decades.
How much do quartz countertops cost in Tampa Bay?
With us, a medium kitchen usually runs $6,000 to $8,000 installed, depending on the level you pick and how much counter you have.
Is quartz OK for an outdoor kitchen in Florida?
Usually not. Most quartz isn’t rated for UV and can fade. Ask about outdoor-rated products or natural stone instead.
Do I need a permit for new countertops?
A straight countertop replacement usually doesn’t. A licensed plumber still handles the sink and faucet connections. If countertops are part of a full remodel, we pull the permit for the whole project.
Where do you install countertops?
As part of kitchen remodels, refinishing and refacing projects across Pinellas and the Tampa Bay area. Local pages: Largo, Clearwater, St. Petersburg, Seminole, Palm Harbor and Dunedin.
Ready to pick your countertops? Book a free consultation. We’ll look at your kitchen, talk through materials and send you a written price. Bayshore Remodels is licensed (CRC1335471) and insured, with 500+ projects across Pinellas and Tampa Bay since 2021. See the rest of our pricing on What It Costs.




