★ 5.0 from 89 Google reviews|Licensed CRC1335471
Services Portfolio About Blog FAQ Schedule a Free Consultation
Refacing or Replacing Kitchen Cabinets: Which Is Best?

Refacing or Replacing Kitchen Cabinets: Which Is Best?

Home โ€บ Blog โ€บ Cabinet Refinishing & Refacing โ€บ Refacing or Replacing Kitchen Cabinets: Which…
The Short Answer

Refacing puts new doors and drawer fronts on the cabinet boxes you already have: from $7,000, most kitchens $10,000–$12,500, 5 to 7 working days on site, with soft-close hinges and drawer slides standard. Replacing cabinets is a full kitchen remodel, from $28,000. Refacing makes sense when the boxes are solid and the layout works, and it can even add a cabinet or two, with new countertops as part of the project.

See cabinet refacing pricing →Refinish, reface or remodel? How to choose →

This question comes up at almost every cabinet consultation we do, and the honest answer depends less on your budget than on what’s going on inside your cabinets. Here’s how we sort it out with homeowners, using our real prices.

Largo kitchen refaced with shaker doors in Delft blue
A Largo kitchen refaced with shaker doors in Delft.

What refacing actually changes, and what it doesn’t

Refacing keeps your existing cabinet boxes in place. We fit new doors and drawer fronts in the style you pick, finish the visible boxes and face frames to match, and install soft-close hinges and drawer slides, which are standard on our refacing jobs. Countertops, sink and appliances usually stay where they are.

What refacing does not change: the size and position of each cabinet, what’s inside the boxes, and the condition of the boxes themselves. If the sink base is soft from an old leak, new doors won’t fix it. That repair has to happen first, and if the damage is widespread, replacement is the honest answer.

What replacement gets you that refacing can’t

  • A new layout. Moving the range, adding an island, widening a walkway or turning a dead corner into usable storage all need new boxes.
  • Better storage inside. Deep drawers instead of base shelves, pull-outs, a tall pantry cabinet, a trash pull-out.
  • Taller wall cabinets. Many 1980s and 1990s Pinellas kitchens have short uppers with a soffit above. Replacement is when that changes.
  • New boxes where water has been. Particleboard that has swelled won’t hold screws or stay square.

The trade-off is cost and time. Replacing cabinets almost always means new countertops, new backsplash and often new flooring at the cabinet edges, which is why we price it as a kitchen remodel rather than a cabinet job.

Side by side

RefacingReplacement (kitchen remodel)
Bayshore priceFrom $7,000; medium $10,000–$12,500; large $13,000–$18,000Small kitchen $28,000–$36,000; full $36,000–$50,000; custom $50,000–$85,000+
On-site time5 to 7 working days; 2 to 3 weeks with new countertops and backsplash3 to 5 weeks small; 4 to 6 weeks full; 6 to 10 weeks custom
LayoutStays the sameCan change
CountertopsUsually stayUsually replaced
Kitchen usable during work?MostlyNo, plan around it
NeedsSound, dry boxesNothing existing has to be reused

Kitchen remodel ranges include new cabinets and countertops. Appliances, light fixtures and faucets are your selections and are priced separately. See what it costs for the full breakdown.

Five questions that usually decide it

  1. Are the boxes sound? Open the sink base and the cabinet under the dishwasher edge. Swelling, soft bottoms or delaminating sides point toward replacement, or at least a localized rebuild before refacing.
  2. Do you like the layout? If you’d change where things are, refacing locks in the current plan.
  3. Are you keeping the countertops? If the granite or quartz is in good shape and you like it, refacing protects that investment. If the countertops are going anyway, the cost gap between refacing and replacing gets smaller.
  4. Do you need more cabinets? Adding a cabinet or two is possible with refacing, but it usually means new countertops over the new section, which moves the job toward 2 to 3 weeks.
  5. How long are you staying? For a sale in the next year or two, refacing or refinishing often makes more sense than a full remodel. If this is the long-term house and the kitchen doesn’t work, spending once on the right layout usually beats refacing now and remodeling later.

When neither is the right call

If you like your door style and only want a new color, cabinet refinishing starts at $5,000 and keeps your existing doors. If only the hardware feels dated, new pulls are a weekend project and you don’t need us. Our guide to refinish, reface or remodel walks through all three options.

What can change the price after you sign

On refacing, the most common surprise is a box that looks fine until the old doors come off and the sink base turns out to be soft. On replacement, it’s what’s behind the old cabinets: an uneven floor, damaged drywall or plumbing that doesn’t line up with the new layout. A good estimate names these possibilities up front and explains how they’d be priced in writing if they show up.

Kitchen cabinets by Bayshore Remodels
A Bayshore kitchen cabinet project.

Frequently asked questions

Is refacing cheaper than replacing cabinets?

Yes, usually by a wide margin, because the boxes, countertops and plumbing stay. Refacing with us starts at $7,000; replacing cabinets is part of a kitchen remodel starting at $28,000.

Can you reface cabinets with water damage?

Not as-is. A localized problem like one sink base can sometimes be rebuilt and then refaced with the rest. Refacing itself doesn’t fix structural damage, and widespread damage means replacement.

Can I add soft-close hinges when refacing?

Soft-close hinges and drawer slides are standard on our refacing jobs.

Will refacing or replacement add more value to my house?

It depends on the house, the neighborhood and what buyers there expect, so be wary of anyone quoting a fixed return. Fix what’s broken first, then spend where it changes how the kitchen works or looks.

We reface and remodel kitchens across Pinellas, including Largo, Clearwater, Belleair, Seminole and Indian Rocks Beach. Not sure which way to go? Book a free consultation. We’ll open the cabinets with you and tell you straight whether refacing will hold up or whether a kitchen remodel is the better spend.

Share this article
Call (813) 489-1552Get My Price